This is a list of players that can be considered the All-Time Best Argos at their Positions. As with every list...there are always differing opinions....but an attempt has been made to be as complete as possible.
| Quarterback 1 | ... | Doug Flutie | ... | (1996-1997) |
| Quarterback 2 | Conredge Holloway | (1981-1986) | ||
| Running Back 1 | Chester 'Cookie' Gilchrist | (1959-1961) | ||
| Running Back 2 | Royal Copeland | (1945-1949, 1954-1956) | ||
| Running Back 3 | Joe 'The King' Krol | (1945-1953, 1955) | ||
| Tight End/Slotback 1 | Dick Shatto | (1954-1965) | ||
| Tight End/Slotback 2 | Mel Profit | (1966-1971) | ||
| Wide Receiver 1 | Terry Greer | (1980-1985) | ||
| Wide Receiver 2 | Paul Masotti | (1988- Present) | ||
| Offensive Centre | Norm Stoneburg | (1955-1958, 1960-1967) | ||
| Offensive Tackle 1 | Dan Ferrone | (1981-1988, 1990-1992) | ||
| Offensive Tackle 2 | Dan Nykoluk | (1955, 1957-1971) | ||
| Offensive Guard 1 | Pierre Verchival | (1993-1997) | ||
| Offensive Guard 2 | Charlie Bray | (1968-1973) | ||
| FG Kicker | Lance Chomyc | (1985-1993) | ||
| Punter | Dave Mann | (1958, 1960-1970) | ||
| All-Purpose | Mike 'Pinball' Clemons | (1989-Present) |
| Defensive Tackle 1 | .... | Jim Stillwagon | .... | (1971-1975) |
| Defensive Tackle 2 | Rodney Harding | (1985-1994) | ||
| Defensive End 1 | Jim Corrigall | (1970-1981) | ||
| Defensive End 2 | James Curry | (1983-1985) | ||
| Middle Linebacker | Jim Andreotti | (1960-1962, 1967) | ||
| Linebacker 1 | Ron Brewer | (1958-1960, 1963-1965) | ||
| Linebacker 2 | Dick Aldridge | (1965-1973) | ||
| Cornerback 1 | Reggie Pleasant | (1987-1994) | ||
| Cornerback 2 | Carl Brazely | (1983-1986, 1988-1992) | ||
| Defensive Halfback 1 | Ed Learn | (1967-1969) | ||
| Defensive Halfback 2 | Dick Thornton | (1967-1972) | ||
| Defensive Safety | Marv Luster | (1964-1972) |
Special thanks to Donald Cobb, Michael Skeet, Ravi Ramkissoonsingh and Jon LeBlanc.